Video Shot by Keith Lamont Scott’s Wife Shows Her Pleading With Officers for His Life
Wife's cellphone video shows police shooting of Keith Lamont Scott
By Wesley Lowery,, Renae Merle and Mark Berman
September 23 at 9:30 PM
CHARLOTTE — The wife of a man fatally shot by police recorded cellphone video of the encounter that includes her pleading with officers not to shoot and begging her husband to get out of his truck.
The video footage was the first glimpse of what happened before and after a shooting that has inflamed this city and prompted intense, sometimes violent protests over the past three days. The recording does not include a view of the shooting itself, which occurred Tuesday afternoon as Keith Lamont Scott, a 43-year-old black man, was sitting in his parked vehicle outside his apartment.
It also does not answer whether Scott had a gun, as police have said. The family, protesters and civic leaders have been demanding that police release department video of the shooting, which the police have not done.
NBC News first published the cellphone video Friday afternoon, and attorneys for the family released it to The Washington Post and other media outlets. It shows an officer aiming a gun at an unseen Scott while police shout at him to drop his gun. Rakeyia Scott can be heard yelling to the officers that her husband was unarmed.
“Don’t shoot him,” she says. “Don’t shoot him. He has no weapon. He has no weapon. Don’t shoot him.”
She then urges her husband to come out of the car and repeatedly says, “Don’t you do it,” until gunshots are heard. At this point, the camera is facing the ground, and she becomes increasingly upset, shouting profanities as she hurries closer to the scene.
“Did you shoot him? He better not f---ing be dead,” she yells while moving along the tree-lined street.
When she gets nearer the scene, at least four officers are seen gathered around someone down on the street. Two of the officers are kneeling over him.
“He better live,” she said. “I swear he better live. Yep. He better live. He better f---ing live.”
Police have said they have no immediate plans to release two recordings of the shooting, one captured by a police dashboard camera and another by a body camera worn by an officer at the scene, according to attorneys for the family.
The black plainclothes officer who shot Scott — Brentley Vinson, who was placed on paid administrative leave — was not wearing a recording device, police said.
Authorities have said officers encountered Scott because they were searching for another man — a suspect with an outstanding warrant. According to police, officers saw Scott get out of a car with a handgun and get back into it, and they ordered him to get out and drop the weapon. Police say he posed a deadly threat and refused to drop the gun.
The unreleased department video of the encounter has become a focal point for demonstrators here, who have taken to the city’s streets and called for footage to be released. Scott’s relatives, including his wife, watched the police videos on Thursday, according to their attorneys, and said they came away with “more questions than answers.”
The footage of an anguished wife of 20 years pleading for her husband’s life came as officials praised Thursday’s protests for being largely peaceful and calm. After Scott’s death Tuesday, Charlotte experienced chaos and violence on its streets for two nights as unrest roiled the city, the latest in a long list of places rocked by protests over policing.
Authorities announced on Friday the arrest of a man in the fatal shooting of a demonstrator during a clash between protesters and police and said a curfew would continue through the weekend.
While a curfew was announced from midnight to 6 a.m., authorities did not enforce it in the early hours of Friday, even as Charlotte remains under a state of emergency and patrolled by National Guard troops. Protesters marching through the streets chanted “What curfew?” and kept going until nearly 2 a.m. Friday in defiance.
On Friday night, around a hundred protesters moved again through the subdued city streets, their chants of “no justice, no peace” ringing out as they approached the area where Scott was killed. In the front of the group was a banner that read “release the tapes.”
Outside the Omni Charlotte Hotel, Diana Ely-Bembry, 21, manned a chalk display on which passers-by wrote messages in memory of black men and women killed by police. “Communicate. Listen. Understand,” she said, when asked what police in Charlotte should be doing.
Capt. Mike Campagna of the Charlotte police said the focus for police on Friday night was to allow the protesters to move peacefully through the streets. “We are going to facilitate.”
He attributed the relative calm of the protests Thursday and Friday nights compared with earlier days to the people of Charlotte seeing what happens when things turn violent. When events did become tense, he said, the key was communication. “A lot of it was talking to people. A lot of it was listening to people.”
Meanwhile, reports suggested that guests had been moved from a nearby hotel earlier in the day, apparently for safety reasons.
Business leaders and others have been unsettled by protests and the shutdown of one of the South’s main commercial hubs. But police also fear that sweeping crackdowns could add fuel to the tensions.
The Guard and state troopers will remain in Charlotte through Sunday, when the Carolina Panthers are set to host the Minnesota Vikings for a football game in the city that afternoon. Police say they have “adequate resources” to secure the city during the event.
Other officials weighed in Friday about whether the video should be released, even as footage from Scott’s wife circulated widely on social media and cable news, making the clip the most widely seen record of what unfolded.
Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton chimed in on Twitter, saying that Charlotte officials should release the police videos “without delay.” Clinton plans to visit Charlotte on Sunday, according to a campaign aide. Donald Trump, her Republican opponent, bemoaned the unrest in Charlotte and said he thought that drugs were a “very, very big factor” in the violence.
Charlotte Mayor Jennifer Roberts (D), however, appealed Friday to the candidates to stay away for now.
“If there would be a way to delay those visits in terms of giving us a chance to get our city back to order and back to more of a state of normalcy, that would probably be ideal,” Roberts told CNN.
Earlier, Roberts said that she thinks the video should be released but that “the question is the timing.” Gov. Pat McCrory (R) said it would be “improper” for him to speak on whether the video should be released while the investigation is ongoing. Attorney General Roy Cooper (D), McCrory’s opponent in the upcoming gubernatorial election, called Friday for releasing the police videos, as well, saying that transparency “breaks down barriers and brings progress.”
Kerr Putney, the Charlotte-Mecklenburg police chief, said that police video footage of the encounter did not give “absolute definitive visual evidence that would confirm that a person is pointing a gun,” but he said that the footage and other evidence “supports what we’ve heard” about what happened.
Putney later told CNN that the video was not from an angle that would show a gun in Scott’s hand, but he said witnesses saw a gun and that one was found nearby. Roberts also said the videos were “inconclusive” and that the footage released Friday by Scott’s family did not show whether he had something in his hand.
[Police are on pace to fatally shoot about as many people in 2016 as they did in 2015]
Scott’s relatives, who asked authorities to show them video of the shooting, watched it on Thursday, attorneys for the family said. In a statement, one of the family’s attorneys, Justin Bamberg, said the videos show Scott calmly leaving his car when asked to do so by police and not raising his hands or acting aggressively.
Bamberg also said the videos do not show whether Scott has anything in his hands, which he said were at his side when he was shot, the footage showed. Scott’s family has called on police to release the videos “as a matter of the greater good and transparency” and called on people to protest peacefully.
Scott is one of at least 708 people shot and killed by police so far this year and the fourth person shot and killed by a Charlotte-Mecklenburg police officer, according to a Washington Post database tracking such deaths.
His death came on the heels of a fatal police shooting in Tulsa and another in Columbus, Ohio, that killed a 13-year-old last week. On Thursday, Officer Betty Shelby, who shot and killed 40-year-old Terence Crutcher in Tulsa last week, was charged with first-degree manslaughter.
Berman reported from Washington. Sarah Larimer and Cleve R. Wootson Jr. in Charlotte; Abby Phillip in White Plains, N.Y.; Jose A. DelReal in Pittsburgh; and William Wan, Louisa Loveluck and Julie Tate in Washington contributed to this report.
By Wesley Lowery,, Renae Merle and Mark Berman
September 23 at 9:30 PM
CHARLOTTE — The wife of a man fatally shot by police recorded cellphone video of the encounter that includes her pleading with officers not to shoot and begging her husband to get out of his truck.
The video footage was the first glimpse of what happened before and after a shooting that has inflamed this city and prompted intense, sometimes violent protests over the past three days. The recording does not include a view of the shooting itself, which occurred Tuesday afternoon as Keith Lamont Scott, a 43-year-old black man, was sitting in his parked vehicle outside his apartment.
It also does not answer whether Scott had a gun, as police have said. The family, protesters and civic leaders have been demanding that police release department video of the shooting, which the police have not done.
NBC News first published the cellphone video Friday afternoon, and attorneys for the family released it to The Washington Post and other media outlets. It shows an officer aiming a gun at an unseen Scott while police shout at him to drop his gun. Rakeyia Scott can be heard yelling to the officers that her husband was unarmed.
“Don’t shoot him,” she says. “Don’t shoot him. He has no weapon. He has no weapon. Don’t shoot him.”
She then urges her husband to come out of the car and repeatedly says, “Don’t you do it,” until gunshots are heard. At this point, the camera is facing the ground, and she becomes increasingly upset, shouting profanities as she hurries closer to the scene.
“Did you shoot him? He better not f---ing be dead,” she yells while moving along the tree-lined street.
When she gets nearer the scene, at least four officers are seen gathered around someone down on the street. Two of the officers are kneeling over him.
“He better live,” she said. “I swear he better live. Yep. He better live. He better f---ing live.”
Police have said they have no immediate plans to release two recordings of the shooting, one captured by a police dashboard camera and another by a body camera worn by an officer at the scene, according to attorneys for the family.
The black plainclothes officer who shot Scott — Brentley Vinson, who was placed on paid administrative leave — was not wearing a recording device, police said.
Authorities have said officers encountered Scott because they were searching for another man — a suspect with an outstanding warrant. According to police, officers saw Scott get out of a car with a handgun and get back into it, and they ordered him to get out and drop the weapon. Police say he posed a deadly threat and refused to drop the gun.
The unreleased department video of the encounter has become a focal point for demonstrators here, who have taken to the city’s streets and called for footage to be released. Scott’s relatives, including his wife, watched the police videos on Thursday, according to their attorneys, and said they came away with “more questions than answers.”
The footage of an anguished wife of 20 years pleading for her husband’s life came as officials praised Thursday’s protests for being largely peaceful and calm. After Scott’s death Tuesday, Charlotte experienced chaos and violence on its streets for two nights as unrest roiled the city, the latest in a long list of places rocked by protests over policing.
Authorities announced on Friday the arrest of a man in the fatal shooting of a demonstrator during a clash between protesters and police and said a curfew would continue through the weekend.
While a curfew was announced from midnight to 6 a.m., authorities did not enforce it in the early hours of Friday, even as Charlotte remains under a state of emergency and patrolled by National Guard troops. Protesters marching through the streets chanted “What curfew?” and kept going until nearly 2 a.m. Friday in defiance.
On Friday night, around a hundred protesters moved again through the subdued city streets, their chants of “no justice, no peace” ringing out as they approached the area where Scott was killed. In the front of the group was a banner that read “release the tapes.”
Outside the Omni Charlotte Hotel, Diana Ely-Bembry, 21, manned a chalk display on which passers-by wrote messages in memory of black men and women killed by police. “Communicate. Listen. Understand,” she said, when asked what police in Charlotte should be doing.
Capt. Mike Campagna of the Charlotte police said the focus for police on Friday night was to allow the protesters to move peacefully through the streets. “We are going to facilitate.”
He attributed the relative calm of the protests Thursday and Friday nights compared with earlier days to the people of Charlotte seeing what happens when things turn violent. When events did become tense, he said, the key was communication. “A lot of it was talking to people. A lot of it was listening to people.”
Meanwhile, reports suggested that guests had been moved from a nearby hotel earlier in the day, apparently for safety reasons.
Business leaders and others have been unsettled by protests and the shutdown of one of the South’s main commercial hubs. But police also fear that sweeping crackdowns could add fuel to the tensions.
The Guard and state troopers will remain in Charlotte through Sunday, when the Carolina Panthers are set to host the Minnesota Vikings for a football game in the city that afternoon. Police say they have “adequate resources” to secure the city during the event.
Other officials weighed in Friday about whether the video should be released, even as footage from Scott’s wife circulated widely on social media and cable news, making the clip the most widely seen record of what unfolded.
Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton chimed in on Twitter, saying that Charlotte officials should release the police videos “without delay.” Clinton plans to visit Charlotte on Sunday, according to a campaign aide. Donald Trump, her Republican opponent, bemoaned the unrest in Charlotte and said he thought that drugs were a “very, very big factor” in the violence.
Charlotte Mayor Jennifer Roberts (D), however, appealed Friday to the candidates to stay away for now.
“If there would be a way to delay those visits in terms of giving us a chance to get our city back to order and back to more of a state of normalcy, that would probably be ideal,” Roberts told CNN.
Earlier, Roberts said that she thinks the video should be released but that “the question is the timing.” Gov. Pat McCrory (R) said it would be “improper” for him to speak on whether the video should be released while the investigation is ongoing. Attorney General Roy Cooper (D), McCrory’s opponent in the upcoming gubernatorial election, called Friday for releasing the police videos, as well, saying that transparency “breaks down barriers and brings progress.”
Kerr Putney, the Charlotte-Mecklenburg police chief, said that police video footage of the encounter did not give “absolute definitive visual evidence that would confirm that a person is pointing a gun,” but he said that the footage and other evidence “supports what we’ve heard” about what happened.
Putney later told CNN that the video was not from an angle that would show a gun in Scott’s hand, but he said witnesses saw a gun and that one was found nearby. Roberts also said the videos were “inconclusive” and that the footage released Friday by Scott’s family did not show whether he had something in his hand.
[Police are on pace to fatally shoot about as many people in 2016 as they did in 2015]
Scott’s relatives, who asked authorities to show them video of the shooting, watched it on Thursday, attorneys for the family said. In a statement, one of the family’s attorneys, Justin Bamberg, said the videos show Scott calmly leaving his car when asked to do so by police and not raising his hands or acting aggressively.
Bamberg also said the videos do not show whether Scott has anything in his hands, which he said were at his side when he was shot, the footage showed. Scott’s family has called on police to release the videos “as a matter of the greater good and transparency” and called on people to protest peacefully.
Scott is one of at least 708 people shot and killed by police so far this year and the fourth person shot and killed by a Charlotte-Mecklenburg police officer, according to a Washington Post database tracking such deaths.
His death came on the heels of a fatal police shooting in Tulsa and another in Columbus, Ohio, that killed a 13-year-old last week. On Thursday, Officer Betty Shelby, who shot and killed 40-year-old Terence Crutcher in Tulsa last week, was charged with first-degree manslaughter.
Berman reported from Washington. Sarah Larimer and Cleve R. Wootson Jr. in Charlotte; Abby Phillip in White Plains, N.Y.; Jose A. DelReal in Pittsburgh; and William Wan, Louisa Loveluck and Julie Tate in Washington contributed to this report.
No comments:
Post a Comment